[Commentary] With India dealing with an egg scarcity, might bugs be a potential resolution for protein and diet?

The photo shows egg cartons for sale, with a man sitting behind them

  • India is among the world’s largest egg producing nations after China and america. Nevertheless, Indian states are presently dealing with acute egg shortages and rising costs.
  • With the egg scarcity and the chicken flu epidemic, the provision of eggs decreases and their costs rise, leaving households that rely upon eggs as the first protein supply with the problem of assembly their dietary wants.
  • Folks want to search out different sources of typical protein, write the authors of this commentary. One such possibility being studied is bugs, that are wealthy in protein, hint parts and iron.
  • The views of this commentary are these of the authors.

India overtook China because the world’s most populous nation on January 17, 2023 — a indisputable fact that left us confused whether or not to have a good time or fear. This was anticipated to occur solely by 2025, in response to the UN inhabitants distribution forecast, however India’s speedy inhabitants development exceeded the forecasts. With such speedy inhabitants development, the larger query is – are we ready sufficient to maintain the rising inhabitants with ample meals and diet?

On the identical day that India turned essentially the most populous nation, the Indian state of Maharashtra was within the headlines for its diet disaster. The state was in need of greater than one million eggs a day. Many nations around the globe have confronted comparable egg shortages previously two years. That is largely as a result of large-scale slaughter of poultry as a result of extremely contagious chicken flu and the availability chain disruption attributable to the pandemic.

This egg scarcity will be thought-about the start of a right away protein scarcity. With the inhabitants anticipated to develop to 9.7 billion by 2050 and 10.4 billion by 2100, the issue is just anticipated to worsen.

Egg vendor in Kolkata. India is among the largest egg producing nations on the planet. Picture by Jorge Royan/Wikimedia Commons.

Egg scarcity in India

India is among the world’s largest egg producing nations after China and america. Nevertheless, Indian states are presently dealing with an acute scarcity of eggs. The rise in egg costs is especially alarming, as eggs are the first supply of protein for many individuals. In keeping with the Nationwide Household Well being Survey (NFHS) 2019-2020 stories, 74 p.c of Indian households eat eggs.

With restricted provide, the value of eggs is already on the rise, up round 25% in wholesale costs in India over the previous yr (Bangalore Rs. 466.6 in January 2022 and Rs. 565 in January 2023).

Resulting from present value inflation and shortages, the nation’s meals safety is a priority.

Per capita consumption of eggs in India has doubled within the final 20 years and elevated greater than a hundredfold within the final 60 years. On the similar time, meat consumption per capita remains to be low, solely 8% of that of developed nations, and has not modified a lot within the final 60 years. Moreover, different protein sources similar to meat, fish, and plant-based sources will not be as available as eggs, though they’re accessible.

The present egg scarcity is because of a number of elements, together with the outbreak of chicken flu, current heavy rains and floods and droughts affecting the state. Some research recommend that adjustments in temperature, rainfall, and humidity can create an atmosphere that’s extra conducive to the unfold of sure chicken flu viruses. For instance, hotter temperatures might improve the survival charge of the virus within the atmosphere and in wild chicken populations, making it simpler for the virus to unfold. Moreover, adjustments in rainfall patterns can result in wetter situations, which may create environments extra conducive to virus development. These adjustments in climate patterns also can have an effect on the distribution and migration patterns of untamed birds, which may improve the probability of avian influenza viruses and different ailments spreading to new areas.

Maharashtra is certainly one of India’s main egg-producing states, and the scarcity might have an effect on egg costs in different elements of the nation. The state authorities has additionally taken steps to extend the availability of eggs by importing eggs from different states and nations.

In the picture, a fried egg on a palm leaf plate in appam
Egg appam. The rise in egg costs is especially alarming, as eggs are the first supply of protein for many individuals. Picture by Dethans/Wikimedia Commons.

Results of egg scarcity

The present egg scarcity and chicken flu epidemic can considerably have an effect on the poorest elements of society. As egg availability declines and costs rise, it may be difficult for households that use eggs as their main protein supply to purchase sufficient to fulfill their dietary wants. This may result in higher dietary insecurity.

As well as, folks could also be pressured to hunt different meals choices which are much less nutritious to fulfill their dietary wants, resulting in a lower in dietary variety.

A substantial a part of the eggs comes from free-range chickens within the village farms, which is a invaluable supply of meals particularly for youngsters and pregnant ladies. Nevertheless, if egg costs rise, people might really feel pressured to promote their eggs to earn extra cash, which might exacerbate the issue of kid malnutrition.

Poultry farmers could also be strongly affected by the scarcity, as they might need to cull birds or cut back manufacturing. This may result in a lower within the revenue of poultry farmers and in flip improve the monetary difficulties of their households.

The picture shows chickens inside the fence
The present egg scarcity is because of a number of elements, together with the outbreak of chicken flu, current heavy rains and floods, and drought. Picture: Varghese Ok James/Wikimedia Commons.

A consequence of elevated egg manufacturing

In keeping with FAO stories, world egg manufacturing elevated by 150 p.c to fulfill rising demand over the previous three many years. In Asia alone, egg manufacturing will quadruple. Though rising manufacturing might appear to be a potential resolution, it’s not a sustainable resolution and has environmental impacts. The carbon footprint of poultry alone is 12.27 kg CO2e/kg, which is 10% of worldwide human-caused greenhouse fuel emissions. The necessities for land and water assets are additionally not far behind. The discharge of methane and nitrous oxide from manure and feed manufacturing are additionally a risk. At such excessive emission ranges, rising manufacturing to fulfill the scarcity has monumental environmental results in the long run. Along with all this, the poultry trade is among the largest causes of antibiotic resistance on the planet. Development hormones and meals components generally used within the poultry trade have been linked to numerous hostile results on human well being, together with early puberty, most cancers, and so on., in addition to environmental issues similar to contamination of soil and water assets with residues.

In the picture, a black insect is sitting on a green leaf
Black soldier flies are one of many few insect species that may be raised on a big scale for consumption. Picture by Billjones94/Wikimedia Commons.

Are bugs a potential resolution?

As a result of egg scarcity, folks have to cut back consumption or discover different substances. This requires an pressing want to modify to different sources of typical protein, which is bugs. Anticipating this, the FAO has been selling bugs as a future protein supply since 2013. Whereas 50 g of eggs present 13 g of protein, the identical quantity of cricket powder can present 35 g of protein. Bugs often additionally comprise numerous micronutrients and iron. The advantages of bugs in comparison with typical protein sources have typically been reported. Bugs are a sustainable different to standard animal protein with minimal useful resource necessities, low greenhouse fuel emissions and a quicker feed conversion charge. They are often grown in quite a lot of media, from natural aspect streams to small containers. As a result of they produce numerous offspring in a single cycle and likewise in a brief technology time, they’re an absolute protein different to resolve the protein disaster.

One necessary query to contemplate right here is why bugs are stored over different plant-based protein sources similar to soybeans. The reply lies in a number of benefits that bugs have, similar to vitality effectivity, a smaller ecological and carbon footprint, and minimal useful resource necessities. Bugs even have a bonus over soybeans as a result of they’ve a variety of important amino acids, that are the constructing blocks of protein. They’re additionally supply of fats and minerals similar to zinc, copper and iron, which are sometimes missing in a plant-based weight loss program. Nevertheless, it is very important be aware that insect farming remains to be a nascent subject that faces many challenges. As well as, some people should overcome cultural and psychological boundaries to just accept bugs as meals.

Learn extra: [Explainer] Entomophagy, or consuming bugs, could possibly be the way forward for meals


Davanzo, J., Dogo, H., and Grammich, CA (2011). Inhabitants traits, coverage implications and financial impacts in China and India by 2025. RAND CORP SANTA MONICA CA.

Nema, P., Nema, S., & Roy, P. (2012). An outline of worldwide local weather change within the present state of affairs and mitigation efforts. Estimates of renewable and sustainable vitality, 16(4), 2329-2336.

Dennis, S. and Fisher, D. (2018). Local weather change and infectious ailments: the subsequent 50 years. Ann. Acad. Med, 47(10), 401-404.

Lekshmi, M., Ammini, P., Kumar, S., & Varela, MF (2017). Meals manufacturing atmosphere and the event of antimicrobial resistance in human pathogens of animal origin. Microorganisms, 5(1), 11. https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2607/5/1/11

The authors are researchers Ashoka Belief for Analysis in Ecology and Surroundings (ATREE).

Banner picture: A vendor of eggs in Delhi. As states in India face egg shortages, folks might have to search out different sources of the standard protein. One such possibility is bugs. Picture: Pallav.journo/Wikimedia Commons.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *